Catering & Pizza Since the 1950s

About

At New Columbus Pizza & Catering Co., we pride ourselves on our traditional recipes and family values, delivering exceptional food.

Our Mission and Values

Proud of our family legacy.

  • Tasty Neapolitan pizza with fresh ingredients in a cardboard box, perfect for takeout.
  • A hand placing pepperoni slices on pizza dough with tomato sauce.
  • A mother and daughter preparing a delicious homemade pizza with fresh ingredients in a cozy kitchen.

Tony carries on his family’s pizza legacy with pride.

A short and sweet title for this section.

Family is at our core.

Tony Cerimele
Position
Sarah Cerimele
Position
Michael Cerimele
Position

Frequently Asked Questions

We’ve compiled a list of frequently asked questions for you.

We serve a variety of traditional pizzas, including cheese, pepperoni, and specialty toppings that change weekly.

Yes, we offer catering services for events from small gatherings to large celebrations, featuring our famous pizzas and homemade recipes.

You can place your order online, by phone, or visit us at our location for takeout.

Absolutely! We have a selection of vegetarian pizzas and can customize dishes to meet dietary needs.

A person using a pizza cutter to slice pizzas inside open boxes, ready for delivery.
A person using a pizza cutter to slice pizzas inside open boxes, ready for delivery.

Experience the Taste of Tradition with Us!

Order Now!