(570) 669-9800

New Columbus Pizza Co.

A Cerimele Family Tradition!!

Call To Action

Taste the Tradition

Homemade recipes since the 1950s.

Experience the heritage of our family-owned pizza shop.

Order Now

Where Family Meets Flavor! text

Family Tradition Meets Quality Pizza

Rooted in Family Heritage

Our rich history is deeply rooted in family traditions and values.

  • Honoring Tradition
  • Community Focused
  • Quality Ingredients

Using Only the Best Ingredients

Our pizzas are crafted with only the finest, freshest ingredients.

  • Family Values
  • Culinary Excellence
  • Passion for Pizza
Delicious hot pizza with toppings in an open takeout box on a restaurant table.

Discover Our Impact and Reach

Explore the metrics that showcase our dedication to quality and community.

15
Years in Business
500+
Catering Events
60+
Family Recipes
  • “Testimonials serve as a persuasive form of social proof, providing clear evidence of a product or service’s value. Their immense power lies in their ability to inspire trust, cultivating confidence in potential customers.”
    Sarah Johnson

Join Our Events!

Participate in our special gatherings.

  • Tasty Neapolitan pizza with melted cheese and sausage toppings on a rustic slate platter.
  • A hand placing pepperoni slices on pizza dough with tomato sauce.
  • A mother and daughter preparing a delicious homemade pizza with fresh ingredients in a cozy kitchen.

Frequently Asked Questions

We’ve compiled a list of frequently asked questions for you.

We serve a variety of traditional pizzas, including cheese, pepperoni, and specialty toppings that change weekly.

Yes, we offer catering services for events from small gatherings to large celebrations, featuring our famous pizzas and homemade recipes.

You can place your order online, by phone, or visit us at our location for takeout.

Absolutely! We have a selection of vegetarian pizzas and can customize dishes to meet dietary needs.

Join Us Today!

Experience the Taste of Tradition with Us!

Order Now!